Holiday Menu

Celebrate with something sweet. Each season we bake a limited pre-order menu of pies, cookies and treats, made from scratch and ready for pick-up at our Niagara Street storefront.

Order ahead for the holidays — call or email to reserve
Call to OrderEmail Us

Thanksgiving Menu

Let us handle dessert this year. Pies, cookie boxes and dinner rolls, made from scratch. Order by November 19th and pick up Tuesday, Nov 24 or Wednesday, Nov 25.

Pies
Pumpkin Pie
$32.00
Apple Pie
$35.00
Chocolate Cream Pie
$35.00
Cookies
Gourmet Cookie Box
$25.00

Rosemary Shortbread, Maple Pumpkin, Cinnamon Roll, Gingerbread Cheesecake

Custom Cut Out Cookies
$54.00

Thanksgiving set or Buffalo Bills set

Mini Cookie Cakes
$12.00

Set of 4 — “Pie” set or Buffalo Bills set

For the Table
Assorted Dinner Rolls
$10.00

Per dozen

Order by

November 19

Or until we’ve reached capacity

Pick Up

November 24 or 25

Tuesday or Wednesday, 8AM–4PM at 1197 Niagara Street

To Order

(716) 878-8821

[email protected]

There will also be other sweet treats in our storefront cases!

Frost Artisan Bakery wheat decorative element

Let’s Talk Dessert

From small gatherings to weddings and all the little moments in between, we’re here to help make your special day extra sweet. Get in touch with us today to learn more about specialty and custom options.

PLEASE NOTE
Due to increased demand, our replies may be slightly delayed. Custom cakes require a 7 – 14 day notice in order to execute.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Please note: Due to increased demand, our replies may be slightly delayed. Custom cakes require a 7 – 14 day notice in order to execute.

Name(Required)
Please note: Orders available for pick-up only during storefront hours Wednesday – Saturday.