Skip to main content

This information is for inspirational purposes only. To learn more about Frost Artisan Bakery’s current menu and custom baked goods, please contact us.

Birthdays and cakes are a classic pairing. However, that doesn’t mean you have to stick to tradition if you don’t want to. Birthdays are a time of joy and self-celebration, and the chance to redefine your own birthday traditions by indulging in birthday cake substitutes. If you want to explore other delightful alternative birthday desserts, now’s the time to ditch the conventional cake.

Why Choose Other Desserts Instead of a Birthday Cake?

Not everyone is a fan of traditional cake, and that’s ok! Whether you want a lighter, healthier dessert or just prefer other sweets, you should choose whatever kind of dessert you want for your birthday. Plus, chances are high you’ve had traditional cakes for just about every other birthday. By choosing alternative birthday desserts, you’re opening yourself and your guests up to options that might just become new favorites.

Birthday Cake Substitutes to Try


If you’ve never had one before, tarts are very similar to pies. The main difference lies in the crust. Tarts typically have a firmer crust and are open-faced, whereas traditional pies usually have a lattice or crust covering on top. Flavors like seasonal fruit, peanut butter mousse, and lemon meringue are popular choices and make for a beautiful, rustic alternative to cake.


Very dense and rich, tortes are luxurious desserts that can be beautifully decorated to suit any party theme or aesthetic. These desserts have characteristics of cakes and mouses since they are often flourless. They’re very elegant, so those looking for a sophisticated dessert might want to consider a torte instead of a classic birthday cake.

Custom Cookies

Custom cutout cookies are perfect for birthday parties. They’re highly customizable, easy to integrate into any party theme, and don’t require utensils and plates to serve. Guests can engage in party activities and nibble on these tasty treats, without any mess or hassle.


If you’re a fan of traditional cake but don’t want to deal with cutting and serving slices, cupcakes are a great alternative. They’re just as delicious, fun, and festive as classic birthday cakes without the need for as many utensils. Cupcakes also allow you to provide your guests with more variety since it’s easy to mix and match flavors with different types of cake, frosting, fillings, and toppings.


Cheesecakes are known for being rich and indulgent. With the right flavor combinations, your cheesecake can balance sweet, rich flavors with tart, fruity accents like curd toppings.

Find Birthday Cake Substitutes with Frost

Frost Artisan Bakery loves helping customers celebrate birthdays, and we embrace the opportunity to bake something new and exciting for your big day. Our menu features homemade options you can tailor to your theme and flavor preferences. Reach out today to talk dessert with our team!